| CHAMPION | HEAD COACH | YEAR | Runner-Up | RUNNER UP HEAD COACH |
Score and Broadcast Link | |
 |
Centerville Demons | Steve Geraghty | 2004 Season - Year I | Philadelphia Phantoms | Roger Slane |
34-15 |
 |
Tokyo Yokozunas | Dennis Crowley | 2005 Season - Year II | Cave Creek Longshots | Mark Long |
31-16 |
| |
Tokyo Yokozunas | Dennis Crowley | 2006 Season - Year III | St. Louis Bandits | Jeff Wendlent |
41-21 |
| |
Tokyo Yokozunas | Dennis Crowley | 2007 Season - Year IV | Philadelphia Phantoms | Roger Slane |
20-13 |
 |
Cave Creek War Eagles | Mark Long | 2008 Season - Year V | Cape Fear Leviathan |
David Bowman | 23-10 |
| |
Tokyo Yokozunas | Dennis Crowley | 2009 Season - Year VI | Dracut Middies | Michael Stucchi | 26-20 |
 |
Orange County Jets |
Rousel Glaciano | 2010 Season - Year VII | Tokyo Yokozunas | Dennis Crowley |
34-28 |
 |
Warren Little Eagles |
Jerry Croyts | 2011 Season - Year VIII | Orange County Jets | Rousel Glaciano |
27-17 |
 |
Brighton River Dogs |
Tyke Wright | 2012 Season - Year IX | River City Raiders | Derek Rose |
24-17 |
| |
Tokyo Yokozunas |
Dennis Crowley | 2013 Season - Year X | Brighton River Dogs | Tyke Wright |
33-14 |
| |
Tokyo Yokozunas |
Dennis Crowley | 2014 Season - Year XI | Chicago Blitz | Ian Power |
34-16 Broadcast |
| |
Tokyo Yokozunas |
Dennis Crowley | 2015 Season - Year XII | Ferdon Fighting Otters | Tyke Wright |
35-31 Broadcast |
|
Cave Creek War Eagles |
Mark Long | 2016 Season - Year XIII | Tokyo Yokozunas | Dennis Crowley | 27-22 Broadcast |
| |
Tokyo Yokozunas |
Dennis Crowley | 2017 Season - Year XIV | Ferdon Fighting Otters | Tyke Wright |
45-34 Broadcast |
 |
Ferdon Fighting Otters |
Tyke Wright | 2018 Season - Year XV | Blue Island Untouchables | Brian Holmberg | 38-10 Broadcast |
 |
Virginia Vipers |
Keith Moubray | 2019 Season - Year XVI | Toledo Wolves | Brendon Long |
19-16 Broadcast |
 |
Wixom Foxes |
Nicholas Hall | 2020 Season - Year XVII | Dracut Middies | Michael Stucchi | 41-19 |
|
Ferdon Fighting Otters |
Tyke Wright | 2021 Season - Year XVIII | Tokyo Yokozunas | Dennis Crowley | 24-17 |
|
Cave Creek War Eagles |
Mark Long | 2022 Season - Year XIX | Jersey Rebels | Joe Golden | 21-20 Broadcast |
|
Westland Foxes |
Nicholas Hall | 2023 Season - Year XX | Ferdon Fighting Otters | Tyke Wright | 26-23 1st Half Broadcast 2nd Half Broadcast |